UPDATED review: Stitchfix #10 (or the one where I can’t decide)

 

UPDATED: Includes my comments, your comments, and what I kept.

I can’t believe this is my 10th Stitchfix (<– referral link). They still feel so new and exciting! (Want to read about my past nine Stitchfixes? Click here.)

When I peeked online, I was excited to see three sleeveless tops and two dresses, which sounded perfect for summer. I did quick Google searches for images and found a few that all looked good. I was very hopeful going into this Stitchfix. Could it be the one where I keep ALL FIVE?

I’m posting without any commentary because I don’t want you to be swayed by my opinions. Okay, go!

ROSCO FLORAL PRINT CROCHET DETAIL TANK, $58

I thought: At first glance, I thought this was cute. Not my color, but nice details and something different. I did think that it’s something that I could likely find at Forever 21 for 1/4 of the price, but I kept the option open.

You thought: “This first tank top is cute but I don’t think it does anything for you.” – Michelle

Verdict? Returned.

ABIGAIL COLORBLOCK LACE TRIM TOP, $58

I thought: Uh oh. These cap-sleeve style tops tend to make my shoulders look very broad, so I’m hesitant. I do love this color of blue, and oddly, I think it kind of makes me look thinner.

You thought: Rave reviews! “LOVE the colorblock + lace top – great color and versatile.” – Katharine

Verdict? Kept it.

CLYDE CENTER PLEAT SLEEVELESS BLOUSE, $48

I thought: Love this color, but it looks pretty big. It fit better on, but the neck was a little wide.

You thought: It had tepid reactions. Everyone said it was nice, but nothing amazing. Good tip: “Target has much cuter & more flattering pleated sleeveless tops for much less than $48.” – Ariana

Verdict? Returned.

AMIRA POLKA DOT FLUTTER SLEEVE DRESS, $68

I thought: Polka dots! Navy! Ruffles! I’m in love … but maybe too many ruffles?

You thought: Most people liked this one, but I still couldn’t quite get on board with it. There was just something about it …

Verdict? Sent it back.

TOULOUSE SLEEVELESS COLLARED WRAP DRESS, $68

I thought: Love the color and I LOVE wrap dresses. I’m not crazy about collars. It buttoned at the bust, but needed one more button below it. (You can see that it’s doing a weird puckering in the middle. ” It looks weird in the boob area,” said Brianna.)

You thought: “What is that, a lab coat?” “No, it’s a wrap dress.” “You say that like I’m supposed to know what that means.” – Convo w/Steve

Verdict? Sent it back, too.

Note: How FAT is my cat?!?

 

So, what should I keep??