What should I keep from Stitch Fix #2??

I need help!

Remember my first Stitch Fix? I loved the service but wasn’t wowed by my options. After finding that I do wear that $68 cardigan a lot, I decided to give Stitch Fix another try. My second order came on Monday, and I asked for no jewelry, everything under $50, and a dress or two since I’m going to a wedding this weekend. (Please remember to ignore the stupid faces that I make.)

I need help deciding what to keep! Please offer your opinions.

Stitch Fix collage — Rosario dress $58; Colibri tab-sleeve blouse $48; Abrianna knit cardigan $48

The dress is cute, but not quite nice enough for the wedding. I consulted with friends and some are concerned that it’s too short for work. I love the color of the blue top, but it feels long to me. The cardigan is awesome, but I got a cardigan last month so I don’t really need another one.

And just FYI, I nixed the two below:

Lyle polka dot stripe mix sheer tank $58; KWallace cotton beaded detail tank $38

The polka dot top was a cute pattern but fit oddly and the tank was a blah color and way too expensive.

So, thoughts? Dress? Blue top? Cardigan? I have to return what I’m not keeping by tomorrow, so let me know!

Another Tale of Stitch Fix (thebrokefashionistas.wordpress.com)
Stitch Fix #3 (mokyandmarisa.wordpress.com)

10 Replies to “What should I keep from Stitch Fix #2??”

Nick B says:

07/03/2013 at 4:35 PM

They all look fabulous but I love the cardigan that’s my favorite color and it looks good on you!!

Reply
Michelle S says:

07/03/2013 at 4:47 PM

Im ur sister so u wont take my consideration, but I like all of them on u except the dress (colors/design) and the polka dot/stripe shirt.

Reply
jacqueline says:

07/03/2013 at 5:24 PM

I think the cardigan! The color and fit is perfect on you!! I would honestly nix the other two… you already talked yourself out of the dress and i have a nearly identical blue top from kohl’s (so you can probably find it for half the price)

Reply
1. Renee L. Beck says:
  
  07/03/2013 at 7:15 PM
  
  Ohh, I’m going to have to scour Kohl’s. Thanks for the tip!
  
  Reply
Renee L. Beck says:

07/03/2013 at 7:14 PM

Alright all, I’m keeping the dress! I decided that the cardigan draped too low in the front and the blouse was just too long and looked frumpy.

Reply
shirarosen88 says:

07/10/2013 at 9:17 PM

I really like the dress:) Good choice- super cute!

http://asequinloveaffair.com

Reply
1. Renee L. Beck says:
  
  07/11/2013 at 8:26 AM
  
  Thanks! Now I just need to wear it somewhere …
  
  Reply
elle @ being stepmom says:

08/04/2013 at 12:44 AM

Love the dress! Have you been able to wear it yet?

Reply
1. Renee L. Beck says:
  
  08/04/2013 at 9:59 AM
  
  Thank you! Yep, I’ve worn it already and it’s really cute and comfortable.
  
  Reply
Pingback: Stitch Fix review #4 | RLB, Ink.